Question for Discussion

[Teeds]

As has already been said there are too many variables to make the discussion valid except as an intellectual exercise. Never the less, it is an interesting point of discussion.

 

For the sake of argument, all things being equal I would say at many levels it would be a toss up and I would most likely look for the spark in their eyes that separates the great from the mundane.

 

That still does not answer your question, but let me explain further.

 

Which would be easier / more effective & efficient?

 

Train Employee "A" to draw and detail properly in CAD, the designs he/she helps create?

 

Train Employee "B" in the business of whatever profession she/he is in so they can design and detail?

 

Assuming that Employee A has been to architectural and/or engineering school generally means almost nothing in my experience. If they have zero real world experience they are void of practical knowledge that defines ability in my world.

 

Assuming that Employee B has been to drafting school again generally means almost nothing in my experience for the same exact reason ... If they have zero real world experience they are void of practical knowledge that defines ability in my world.

 

Now, that being said, I will admit that I would be biased to choose the drafter over the designer because of the following logic ... or lack thereof ... LOL

 

The drafter has chosen to learn to be a communicator and communication is the foundation of good design. Good design cannot be taught but without the ability to communicate the design, nothing can be realized by the efforts of the designer. All too many people in the design fields see drafting (i.e. communication) as the most tedious part of their training and rush through it to get on to the more “interesting” aspects of the profession ... be it architecture or engineering.

 

There is a incredible level of elegance in being able to effectively communicate good design. At the same time, it takes a tremendous amount of effort to make things look, and feel, simple. Design and detailing go hand in hand and understanding of the materials is paramount to being able to elegantly solve a problem, be it architectural, engineering or process.

 

There was a world renown architect in San Antonio named O’neal Ford. His ability to work with brick was, and frankly is, legendary. When asked why he understood the material so well, he would say because during the depression he made brick in order to live.

 

Understanding of the materials of your profession are paramount to real success as a designer/drafter.

 

The very best are good at both.

[GCarr78]

We find ourselves in total agreement! How did that happen?

 

 

LOL ah well, we can't win em all can we?